By INS Contributors
KUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia: The Committee on Talent, Youth and Education and the PhD Candidate Development Centre of the Malaysia-China Trade & Economic Advancement Association jointly organised the inaugural session of the Malaysia-China PhD Candidates “Voices on the Research Journey” Academic Development Series, focusing on how PhD candidates can improve their chances of getting academic papers published.
The session addressed key concerns commonly faced by PhD candidates, including research capacity building, international journal submissions, academic integrity and the use of artificial intelligence in research.
Prof Ho Chin Kuan, Executive Council Member of the Malaysia-China Trade & Economic Advancement Association, Vice Chancellor of Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation (APU), and researcher at the Overseas Chinese Development Research Centre of the Yangtze Delta Region Institute of Tsinghua University, and Prof Jason Turner, Editor-in-Chief of Asian Education and Development Studies, were the guest speakers.
The session was moderated by Zhang Weijing of the Association’s PhD Candidate Development Centre. Also present were Zhang Zheng, Executive Secretary of the Malaysia-China Trade & Economic Advancement Association; Zhao Fei, Administrative Secretary; Hu Jiangtao, Deputy Secretary-General of the Committee on Talent, Youth and Education; and 68 PhD candidates from different universities, countries and ethnic backgrounds.
Prof Ho approached the discussion from the perspective of doctoral research and long-term academic development, sharing his views on research capabilities, research tools, academic collaboration and personal well-being.
He said pursuing a PhD should not be seen merely as a process of completing a thesis and obtaining a degree, but more importantly as an opportunity to develop the ability to identify research problems, conduct independent research and exercise sound academic judgement.
He encouraged PhD candidates to make full use of their time as students by actively engaging with their supervisors and making use of academic resources available at their universities. Continuous learning, communication and research training, he said, were essential to strengthening knowledge, research methodology and academic capabilities.
Addressing the rapid development of AI and other research tools, Prof Ho also gave a practical demonstration of their applications. He said new technologies could help improve efficiency in literature searches, information organisation and research analysis, but should never replace researchers’ own reading, critical thinking and academic training.
PhD candidates, he added, must understand the boundaries between the appropriate use of technology and academic integrity, while remaining fully responsible for their research process and academic output.
Prof Ho also highlighted the importance of physical and mental well-being throughout the PhD journey. As doctoral studies often take several years, he said students should learn to manage the pressures associated with research, publication and graduation requirements while maintaining a healthy balance between academic work and personal life.
Drawing on his own doctoral experience, he also stressed the importance of research teams and peer support, encouraging PhD candidates to regularly share their progress, discuss challenges and support one another throughout their academic journey.
Prof Jason Turner, meanwhile, offered insights from the perspective of an international journal editor, explaining the current academic publishing environment and the considerations behind editorial decisions.
He said researchers should not focus solely on writing a good paper, but should also understand what their target journals are publishing, what topics they are currently interested in and where research gaps remain.
Before submitting a manuscript, researchers should study recently published articles and the research direction of their target journals, including thematic focus, geographical coverage and existing research gaps. They should also clearly demonstrate the originality, theoretical contribution, practical relevance and international or regional significance of their work.
Prof Turner advised PhD candidates to identify journals that genuinely match their research topics and findings rather than selecting publications solely on the basis of journal rankings.
He also encouraged researchers to follow recent articles published by their target journals, communicate professionally with editors and participate in peer review where appropriate. Such engagement, he said, could help young researchers better understand the international publishing process while expanding their academic networks.
Rejection should also be assessed objectively, he said, as editorial decisions may be influenced by factors including the fit between a manuscript and the journal, submission timing and the number of similar papers already under consideration.
During the interactive session, PhD candidates raised questions on the appropriate use of AI in academic research, repeated rejection by international journals, publication planning and academic networking.
Responding to questions on AI, Prof Turner said researchers using AI for appropriate supporting purposes should comply with the relevant journal policies and make the necessary disclosures. Research ideas and the core academic work, however, must remain the researchers’ own.
On questions concerning repeated rejection from SSCI Q2 education journals and whether several papers could be developed simultaneously, Prof Turner said rejection did not necessarily indicate fundamental weaknesses in the research. Editorial decisions could also be affected by a journal’s scope, the number of similar submissions received and its current editorial priorities.
He encouraged PhD candidates to be more strategic when selecting journals and to manage research projects at different stages according to their own progress, while using academic collaboration to maintain continuity in their research.
Both Prof Ho and Prof Turner stressed that there is no simple “shortcut” to improving publication success. While effective publication strategies and research tools can enhance efficiency, high-quality research remains the foundation of academic publishing.
They encouraged PhD candidates to understand the rules and practices of international academic publishing while using their doctoral years to systematically strengthen their research capabilities and gradually establish their own academic directions through continuous learning, engagement and practice.
Zhang Zheng, Executive Secretary of the Malaysia-China Trade & Economic Advancement Association, said the Malaysia-China PhD Candidates “Voices on the Research Journey” Academic Development Series was established to address the practical research, academic and professional development needs of PhD candidates.
“The series aims to provide a platform connecting PhD candidates with university academics, journal experts and professionals, enabling them to gain practical insights and engage directly with experienced members of the academic community,” he said.
He added that the Committee on Talent, Youth and Education and the PhD Candidate Development Centre would continue to organise activities covering academic publishing, research methodology, academic integrity, research tools and career development, providing more diverse opportunities for academic exchange and professional growth among Malaysian and Chinese PhD candidates and young researchers.
0 Comments
LEAVE A REPLY
Your email address will not be published